The lyrics of "Carnival of Sorts (Box Cars)" by R.E.M. are open to interpretation and can be analyzed in various ways. Here's one possible interpretation:
1. **Mystery and Secrecy**: The song opens with the line, "There's a secret, stigma, reaping wheel," suggesting a sense of mystery and secrecy. The use of "stigma" implies that there's something hidden or taboo. The "reaping wheel" may symbolize the consequences or judgment that comes with uncovering this secret.
2. **Repetition and Structure**: The song is characterized by repetition, with certain phrases and lines being repeated multiple times. This repetition creates a hypnotic and somewhat disorienting effect, which can be seen as mirroring the themes of secrecy and the unknown.
3. **Chronic Town**: The mention of "Chronic Town" may refer to a place or state of being that is characterized by chronic issues or problems. The "poster torn" could indicate a sense of decay or deterioration in this town.
4. **Stranger to These Parts**: The repeated reference to being a "stranger" suggests a sense of alienation or not belonging. This feeling of being an outsider is reinforced by the lines "Stranger, stranger to these parts."
5. **Gentlemen Don't Get Caught**: This line implies that there are rules or codes of conduct, and "gentlemen" are expected to adhere to them. The idea of not getting caught could suggest a fear of consequences or judgment.
6. **Box Cars**: The repeated mention of "box cars" pulling out of town might symbolize a desire to escape or move on from whatever is happening in this place. Box cars are often associated with travel and movement.
7. **Cages Under Cage**: The repetition of "cages under cage" could represent a sense of confinement or entrapment, possibly within the constraints of societal norms or expectations.
8. **Overall Mood**: The lyrics create a sense of unease, mystery, and detachment. The song's structure and repetition contribute to this atmosphere, making it feel like a hypnotic and somewhat surreal experience.
Overall, "Carnival of Sorts (Box Cars)" appears to explore themes of secrecy, alienation, societal expectations, and the desire for escape. The song's lyrics are open-ended, allowing listeners to interpret them in their own way and find personal meaning within the cryptic and repetitive verses.
Leave your comment here: