Old Crow Medicine Show / Volunteer / 2018
Old Hickory
elegiac, wistful, tinged with dark humor
A ballad about a gifted, self-taught musician named Virgil Lee whose talent curdles into self-destruction and is ultimately forgotten by everyone but the narrator. The old hickory tree becomes the song's central image: something that once gave shelter and life, now standing alone as the only proof a house, and a man, ever existed.
forgotten genius addiction and self-destruction rural folklore memory versus legacy authenticity versus performance
Who's speaking
A first-person narrator who knew Virgil Lee personally, recalling him as both witness and mourner; the voice is affectionate and somewhat awed, but not entirely reliable since the story leans on folk exaggeration and hearsay.
What happens
The song opens with tall-tale descriptions of Virgil Lee's near-mythic boyhood talents, then narrows to a specific memory of hearing him play with startling, untaught brilliance. From there it tracks his decline into substance abuse, his music growing darker as his life unravels, and ends with his death and burial, followed by the narrator's insistence that despite being forgotten, Virgil Lee was the best there ever was.
How it's built
Verse-chorus form with two recurring choruses that alternate and eventually merge at the end. One chorus moralizes about honesty versus performance; the other returns to the hickory tree image, functioning as a refrain of mourning. The final verses compress time rapidly, moving from drinking to death to burial in a few lines, mirroring how quickly a life and its memory can vanish.
Section by section
Opening verse
The introduction builds Virgil Lee as a folk hero through exaggerated feats and natural wisdom, establishing him as someone shaped by the land rather than formal training.B ut the closing image complicates this, suggesting that the same openness that made him remarkable also left him vulnerable.
First chorus
“You can lie like a penny on the CNO line”
This chorus shifts from character sketch to moral commentary, contrasting surface deception with an unseen, higher truth. It works as commentary on both Virgil Lee's self-deception and broader human posturing.
Hickory chorus
The tree metaphor is introduced here as the emotional anchor of the song, turning a specific man's story into something more universal about impermanence and the stubbornness of memory.
Glow Worm Bar verse
“I don't know, I guess I made it up”
This moment captures pure, unselfconscious creativity, the kind of talent that seems to arrive from nowhere. The narrator's astonishment underscores how rare and fleeting that gift seemed, foreshadowing its loss.
Decline verse
The description of a fiery, painful summer marks the turning point where music becomes a vessel for suffering rather than celebration, as Virgil Lee's playing grows erratic and emotionally raw.
Death and burial verse
“when you get too big for your breeches”
This folksy idiom softens a harsh truth, delivering Virgil Lee's downfall with the same storytelling ease used for his earlier triumphs. The instruments hung up in a gym, rather than preserved or played, signal how quickly and unceremoniously his legacy fades.
Final chorus
The repetition of the hickory image at the song's close, now doubled and extended, lingers on absence rather than presence, closing the song on the idea that memory itself becomes the only monument left.
Craft
- extended metaphor
- The hickory tree sheltering a now-demolished house stands in for Virgil Lee himself: once vital and protective of something larger, now solitary and surviving only as a marker of what's gone.
- folk hyperbole
- Early descriptions of Virgil Lee outrunning a train and befriending a wild animal establish him as a legendary, almost supernatural figure, which makes his later fall feel more tragic by contrast.
- juxtaposition
- The moralizing chorus about liars and jokers sits against the hickory chorus about memory, contrasting human deception with the tree's mute, honest permanence.
- symbolic burial detail
- Hanging up his instruments in a gym rather than a proper memorial suggests how casually and incompletely his genius was honored.
Reading it
The most persuasive reading treats this as a song about how folk talent and folk tragedy are often indistinguishable from legend-making itself: Virgil Lee may be an invented or composite figure, a vessel for ideas about raw genius being swallowed by addiction and obscurity. An alternative reading takes him as a specific, perhaps real, local musician the band knew of or heard stories about, making the song closer to an act of oral-history preservation than pure allegory. Both readings converge on the same emotional core: talent unrecognized in life survives only through someone else's telling.
Context
Old Crow Medicine Show has long drawn on old-time and bluegrass storytelling traditions, often writing character-driven narratives rooted in Appalachian and Southern folklore. 'Old Hickory' fits the album's broader interest (as suggested by the title 'Volunteer', evoking Tennessee) in regional identity and oral history, though I don't have confirmed biographical details tying the song to a specific real person.
Listen for
- the shift in vocal tone between the matter-of-fact verses and the more mournful chorus melody
- how the fiddle or guitar lines might mimic the 'twisted, falling down' description of Virgil Lee's later playing
- the way the hickory imagery repeats and extends in the final chorus, suggesting lingering grief
- any instrumental solo that might function as a stand-in for Virgil Lee's own playing, offering the listener a taste of the genius described in the lyrics
About Old Crow Medicine Show
Old Crow Medicine Show is an Americana string band based in Nashville that has been recording since 1998. They were inducted into the Grand Ole Opry on September 17, 2013.
1998 - present / United States
Full biography and catalogue